November 30th 2004 >> Source: Press
Democrat
Amy's Kitchen expanding in Oregon
Lower operating costs lure SR organic
food company; local jobs not affected.
By MICHAEL COIT
Fast-growing Amy's Kitchen is expanding into Medford, Ore.,
giving that city up to 200 jobs that will not be added in Santa
Rosa because of costly operating expenses, owner Andy Berliner
said Monday.
The organic frozen foods processor will keep its Santa Rosa
operation and some 700 jobs here. But local and state officials
invested considerable political capital in urging the company
to expand in Santa Rosa, and Amy's Kitchen came to symbolize
California's high business costs.
"You never like to leave with any part. We have the room
to expand here," Berliner said. "You're comparing
overhead costs. If over the years things go in the direction
we hope, if the costs get more competitive, we would love to
expand in Santa Rosa."
Keeping Amy's Kitchen in Santa Rosa is important to Sonoma
County, community leaders said, but they had hoped the additional
jobs from the company's expansion would have bolstered the
region's sluggish economic recovery.
"I'm disappointed, but probably not very surprised. I
knew it would be hard," said Santa Rosa Mayor Sharon Wright,
who talked with company officials about ways to cut costs and
fees. "It's an issue of economics. It makes it a real
challenge to be competitive."
Local and state officials emphasized that Amy's Kitchen could
have left Santa Rosa entirely given potential cost savings
elsewhere, particularly for electricity and workers' compensation
insurance. Berliner, however, said the company never intended
to pull up stakes here.
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger made a personal pitch to Berliner,
singling out Amy's Kitchen as an example of the need to reduce
costs for doing business in the state.
"The governor's thrilled that Amy's Kitchen has decided
to stay in California, keep the headquarters here and the manufacturing
here," said Vince Sollitto, a spokesman for the governor. "At
the same time, the company's decision to expand outside our
state shows the problem with the business climate. We've made
tremendous progress. But there's no doubt that much more needs
to be done."
Given the company's growth, Santa Rosa still could gain jobs
in the future, and that is why it is important to keep Amy's
Kitchen based here, said Ben Stone, executive director for
the Sonoma County Economic Development Board.
"It's a setback. They had enough reasons to go elsewhere," he
said. "If you can't have the whole loaf, having most of
the loaf, that's really important."
Berliner said the timing of the company's announcement was
linked to a hearing Thursday where California utility regulators
were to discuss giving Amy's Kitchen an electricity rate cut
if they expanded in Santa Rosa. Berliner said the company is
withdrawing the request, which was controversial because Amy's
Kitchen would have received a special discount not yet available
to other companies.
"We didn't feel it was proper to ask for it, because
our intention was to do it (expand) up there," Berliner
said.
Amy's Kitchen expects to purchase a Medford site in about
two weeks and then plan its project there. The production,
distribution and warehouse facility could cover as much as
200,000 square feet and employ up to 200 workers. Amy's Kitchen
aims to open it by January 2006.
The company also will eventually need further expansion on
the East Coast to keep pace with strong demand in that region.
Founded in 1987, Amy's Kitchen has grown from five workers
to 700 at its complex in a Santa Rosa industrial park and could
outgrow the site in a little more than a year.
Annual growth is about 25 percent, but operating costs have
limited profits to about 3 percent, according to the company.
Amy's Kitchen could double or triple that number in Oregon.
The company has $100 million in annual sales.
The Medford operation should save about $1 million in annual
operating costs compared with expanding in Santa Rosa, led
by much lower workers' compensation insurance premiums and
electricity rates, in addition to lower land costs and corporate
taxes. Moving the entire company to Medford would have saved
$4 million a year, Berliner said.
Expanding in Santa Rosa also would have cost the company nearly
$700,000 in city permit fees for a 70,000-square-foot facility.
"Overall, we're looking for the best deal," Berliner
said, adding the company never planned to leave Santa Rosa
altogether. "We already have a tremendous investment here
in equipment and people. We still believe it would be helpful
to stay in California long term."
Citing confidentiality agreements, local and state officials
familiar with the Medford bid for Amy's Kitchen said they couldn't
discuss specific enticements used to lure the company.
But lower costs to do business have helped attract businesses
from other states, including a handful from California in recent
years.
"If all the economic indicators stack up nicely, then
you make the short list for a company," said Brad Hicks,
president and CEO for the Medford/Jackson County Chamber of
Commerce. "Some of those things we don't need to sell
very hard."
Lighthouse Worldwide Solutions expanded in Medford rather
than in the South Bay because of cost savings.
"If you had a checklist, you would go down and say positive,
positive, positive. It's all about profits," said Demi
DeSoto, marketing director for the San Jose-based manufacturer
of quality control instruments.
In addition to cost savings, Medford also offers distribution
advantages. The city sits on Interstate 5 for trucking, has
a busy regional airport with air cargo services and a railroad
connection.
Like Sonoma County, the economy for Medford, with about 70,000
residents, and its surrounding area has become more diverse.
While lumber remains an important sector, Medford has become
a regional retail and medical care hub for southern Oregon.
+
Read Full Article | << Back
to 2004

|